Original Indigenous Economies
Published April 21, 2020
Prior to European contact, indigenous peoples had a long history of engaging in the dynamic economies and governance structures that we recognize today as the necessary ingredients for prosperity. Traditional systems of governance, clear ownership claims, and robust trade networks allowed indigenous peoples to innovate and prosper in a changing world.
- Read "Native American Heritage: It’s Not What You Think," by Terry Anderson via Defining Ideas, Hoover Institution
- Read "Liberty in Perfection: Freedom in Native American Thought," by Amy Sturgis via Foundation for Economic Education
- Read "Treat All Men Alike: Chief Joseph and Respect," via the Bill of Rights Institute
Native Americans have been asking politicians to recognize their rights since before 1879, when Chief Joseph said, “Let me be a free man -- free to travel, free to stop, free to work, free to trade where I choose, free to choose my own teachers, free to follow the religion of my fathers, free to talk, think and act for myself.”
Early in the history of the United States, Native Americans lost sovereignty over their lives and jurisdiction over their land. The federal government forced them onto reservations, declared them wards of the state, and stripped them of their dignity. The federal government restricts individual and tribal rights to this day. This is the main reason why American Indians are the poorest in the United States. But it was not always that way. Prior to European contact, indigenous peoples had a long history of the dynamic economies and governance structures that we recognize today as the necessary ingredients for prosperity.
Native Americans claimed their territories, made capital investments, and rewarded individual initiative. In the Southwest, agricultural peoples established clear ownership of floodplains, marking and enforcing land boundaries to reward stewardship. In the Southeast, families and clans owned cultivated gardens and orchards. Farther North, people marked trees to denote tribal boundaries, important pathways, and to claim forests for hunting, trapping, and timber. And along the Pacific, tribes used stones and marked trees to indicate ownership of spawning streams, fishing weirs, and clam gardens created by terracing beaches. Where societies considered land to be owned communally, individuals, families and clans were generally entitled to the benefits of their work on that land.
While indigenous peoples were diverse, they all had well-established rules recognizing the ownership claims that allowed individuals, families, clans, and tribes to specialize in production and engage in trade. Long before colonization, robust trade networks connected tribes and the goods they produced. People from all over the continent gathered in places like Chaco Canyon in New Mexico to trade everything from salmon, to pearls, to buffalo hides, copper, and obsidian.
In these hubs, trading languages, such as Chinook in the Northwest and Mobilian in the Southeast, emerged to make it easier to exchange goods and share knowledge. Plains tribes improved their nutrition with Pacific salmon and coastal tribes stayed warm with buffalo robes from the interior. Trade fostered prosperity, allowing many tribes to devote significant time and resources to leisure, art, and religious ceremonies.
To support all of this economic activity, tribal governments evolved to fit regional conditions consistent with their customs and culture. This enabled indigenous economies to adapt successfully to climate and technological changes. Indigenous traditions of treaty-making and trade allowed Native Americans to adapt and prosper by trading with Europeans who brought beads, steel, horses, and other new commodities. Plains Indians, for example, became very successful horse societies.
Native Americans didn’t simply survive, they thrived.
Eventually, however, as European settlement expanded, these dynamic decentralized indigenous institutions were forcibly replaced by centralized federal authority. This had dire consequences for Native Americans. Tribes were driven from their traditional territories and onto reservations where tribal practices — like the sun dance and potlatch — were banned. What was once a relatively free, prosperous, and open society of indigenous economies was replaced with top-down, federal control that stripped indigenous peoples of their autonomy, dignity, and sources of wealth. In order for Native Americans to prosper again, they must regain the freedom and sovereignty to enjoy the same rights that other Americans take for granted.